So let me get this straight...guys like girls who eat a lot, but only if they're skinny?

Males are stupid and don't know what they want. You have to tell them what they want. They don't even know why they like skinny girls they're just brainwashed by society. Like they're going to be with a skinny girl who beats them or treats them like crap or makes them feel horrible just because she's skinny. right. ( sarcasm ) They will like anybody that treats them nicely and even some who don't any size or shape.